Malt vs Shake Differences

Even though malts and shakes are prepared with the same elements, they are unique in their own varying ways. The differences are so vast that pitching them against each other will be futile.
I am aware of the discrepancies between the two drinks, so I’m here to clear the air today and set records straight so that you, too, will know once and for all that it is a futile venture trying to compare them.

Let’s proceed.

Malt Vs Shakes The Basics

Malt vs shakes

First of all, these are two very different drinks! They vary in appearance, taste, and process of creation. We’ll take a closer look at each drink and how it’s made.

What is a Shake?

hat is a Shake drink

It is an addictive mixture of ice cream and milk mixed up until it’s drinkable, and it frequently comes with smooth whisked cream and a maraschino cherry to crown it all off. They’re cold and sleek and, yeah, super delicious.

From a technical standpoint, a milkshake is what it sounds like: milk, with some type of spicing syrup, jiggled until it’s cold and frothy. Think what you’d get if you brought about chocolate milk in a cocktail shaker with ice.

When you request a “milkshake,” you’re really only asking for a combined beverage formulated from milk, flavoring, and ice cream.

What is a Malt?

What is malt drink

Malt, also recognized as malted shake, is a variety of milkshakes that can still be located at soda shops and diners.

Formulated in 1922 by Walgreens craftsperson Ivar “Pop” Coulson, the malted milkshake quickly became prominent. The only characteristic that differentiates a malt from a milkshake is that malted milk powder is added after blending the milk and ice cream. The inclusion of malted milk powder strengthens the malt’s flavor, making it sweeter and giving it a thicker consistency.

Nevertheless, the addition of malted milk powder to a malt alters a few components between these two sweet soda fountain drinks. The malt in a malted milkshake gives it a more compliment taste than a traditional milkshake.

A traditional milkshake is sweet and smooth, while the malt is tastier with a thicker consistency. Also, malt has a narrowly more significant percentage of nutrients due to the malt powder’s barley.
It is expedient to note that, even though malt improves specific ingredients, it does not blend well with some fruit-flavored ice creams and syrups.

What Is Malted Milk Powder?

Malted milk powder is prepared from malted barley, wheat flour, and evaporated whole milk. The malt itself is a variety of sugars that have been taken out from barley and other grains after they have been soaked, germinated, and dried.

It is then roasted to caramelize some of the sugars and offer it that rich toasted flavor. The conclusive derivative is the exact ingredient that you discover in Whoppers Malted Milk Balls.

Milk vs Shake: What are their Differences/Similarities?


Where Did The Malt and Milkshake Originate From?
Both malts and milkshakes are typical American dishes. Except for that, back then, they weren’t family-friendly. Milkshakes first came around the first years of the 1800s, and they even contained whiskey for its relish.

The history of the first milkshakes was first documented in 1885, but they weren’t anything like the dessert we enjoy today. They mostly were comparable to eggnog and were an adults-only drink. By the 1900s, though, the whiskey was supplanted with syrup, making it accessible for all ages.

Making milkshakes weren’t a straightforward achievement; back then, they were hand-mixed, and you can guess, that mixing everything concurrently took a tremendous amount of work and muscle power.
In 1922 though, that all improved.

The blender was developed by Steven Poplawski, which considerably cut out work duration and energy expended. This modern invention paved the way for the invention of the malt.

Ivar “Pop” Coulson, a Walgreens laborer at the time, developed the first malted milkshake by stirring ice cream into a malted milk drink. Until then, malted milk drinks were prepared by combining milk, chocolate syrup, and a spoonful of malt powder in a metal compartment, then whipping the mixture into a glass.
On one particularly heated summer day in 1922, Pop Coulson shot off his revolution.


The procedure and the ingredient distinctions in shake and malt have varied calorie amounts. There are roughly 350 calories in a milkshake, while there are only 230 calories in malt beverages. Therefore, when you are selecting high-quality canned baked beans for your keto diet but still yearning for some candies in the afternoon, you can get a cup of malt and then cheerfully get back to the calories-burning training.

Nutritional Value

The malt drinks are malt powdered milk that renders the drink more valuable than shakes. The malted grains comprise proteins and other essential vitamins such as folate, phosphorus, and riboflavin.

Sugar Content

The quantity of flavoring and sugar is slightly higher in order for the shake and malt to taste great.
The classic milkshakes have between 55 and 60 grams of sugar, while malts have 18 to 25 grams of sugar.


Malted milk powder enhances the flavor and makes malt sweeter than a shake. In truth, malted milk is a sweetener with a vibrant, toasty flavor, which delivers the beverage with a thicker density.
The most remarkable thing about malt milk, vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry is that they are in various categories. Note that the more malt milk you add to your shake, the thicker it evolves.


Milkshakes and malt are primarily made in a milkshake machine.

Select an acceptable type of blender to make these cool and tasty drinks at home. Add all the elements into your blender and stir the milkshake until you have the texture you desire.
First, you’re required to put ice cream, milk, and seasoned syrup if you wish to create your own malt at home and mix until it gets a smooth texture. Then, add malt milk powder and blend for a few seconds to integrate the powder rightly.


Malts are not only sturdier than milkshakes; they also taste sweeter than milkshakes. The malt powder is completely savory, but when combined with the rest of the elements in your classic milkshake, it renders the malted drink sweeter than the actual dish. The malted powder also generates a thicker, creamier texture than the milkshake would by itself.


The debate on Malt vs. Milkshake is eternal as there are several viewpoints to see things from.
But like I stated from the very beginning, it all boils down to personal preference and choice.
Thank you for reading!

Leave a comment